Terre Napoleón; a History of French Explorations and Projects in Australia — Text and Context

(0 User reviews) 1812

In Category - Modern Nations

Authors: Scott, Ernest, Sir, 1868-1939 Digital Source: Project Gutenberg Gutenberg Release Year: 2005 First Publication Year: Not confirmed

Key Word: Napoleon I, Emperor of the French, 1769-1821; Australia -- Discovery and exploration; Baudin, Nicolas, 1754-1803 Target Reader: Readers of public-domain and historical texts

Book Edition: Project Gutenberg digital edition Book Language: en

Edition facts

Words 85,089

Reading time 370 min

Text sections 7

The source record for Terre Napoleón; a History of French Explorations and Projects in Australia — Text and Context measures this digital text at 85,089 words, 6 hr 10 min estimated reading time, and 7 detected text sections.

The text analysis averages about 22.7 words per sentence, while the detected sections provide another way to judge how the source is divided.

Project Gutenberg metadata also associates the work with “Napoleon I, Emperor of the French, 1769-1821,” connecting these edition facts with the source record’s subject description.

Source: Project Gutenberg record #7450

Ernest Scott examines the Baudin expedition (1800–1804) and the naming of 'Terre Napoleon' on Australian coasts, scrutinizing claims of a political motive behind Napoleon's scientific voyage.

Editorial Edition Score 4.8/5

★★★★★ ★★★★★

Calculated from edition completeness, EPUB availability, text structure and catalogue metadata. Not a user rating.

How this score is calculated

Description quality20 pts
Title & short description10 pts
Source metadata20 pts
Text length15 pts
Chapters / structure15 pts
EPUB file integrity20 pts

Total of 100 points, scaled to a 2.5-5.0 range. Editions with an empty description or a missing EPUB file are not scored.

Edition quality

File: pg7450

Read the Text

CHAPTER 1. FLINDERS AND THE INVESTIGATOR.

The Investigator at Kangaroo Island. Thoroughness of Flinders' work. His aims and methods. His explorations; the theory of a Strait through Australia. Completion of the map of the continents. A direct succession of great navigators: Cook, Bligh, Flinders, and Franklin. What Flinders learnt in the school of Cook: comparison between the healthy condition of his crew and the scurvy-stricken company on the French vessels.

CHAPTER 2. THE AFFAIR OF ENCOUNTER BAY.

Meeting of the Investigator and Le Geographe in Encounter Bay. Flinders cautious. Interview of the two captains. Peron's evidence. The chart of Bass Strait. Second interview: Baudin inquisitive. Baudin's account of his explorations.

CHAPTER 3. PORT PHILLIP.

Conflict of evidence between Baudin, Peron, and Freycinet as to whether the French ships had sighted Port Phillip. Baudin's statement corroborated by documents. Examination of Freycinet's statement. The impossibility of doing what Peron and Freycinet asserted was done.

CHAPTER 4. TERRE NAPOLEON AND ITS NOMENCLATURE.

Imprisonment of Flinders in Mauritius. The French atlas of 1807. The French charts and the names upon them. Hurried publication. The allegation that Peron acted under pressure. Freycinet's explanations. His failure to meet the gravest charge. Extent of the actual discoveries of Baudin, and nature of the country discovered. The French names in current use on the so-called Terre Napoleon coasts. Difficulty of identifying features to which Baudin applied names. Freycinet's perplexities. The new atlas of 1817.

CHAPTER 5. DID THE FRENCH USE FLINDERS' CHARTS?

Assertions commonly made as to French plagiarism of Flinders' charts. Lack of evidence to support the charges. General Decaen and his career. The facts as to Flinders' charts. The sealed trunks. The third log-book and its contents; detention of it by Decaen, and the reasons for his conduct. Restoration of Flinders' papers, except the log-book and despatches. Do Freycinet's charts show evidence of the use of Flinders' material? How did the French obtain their chart of Port Phillip? Peron's report to Decaen as to British intentions in the Pacific and Indian Oceans, and the effect on his mind. Liberation of Flinders. Capture of Mauritius by the British. English naval officers and the governor. Later career of Decaen.

CHAPTER 6. THE MOTIVES OF BONAPARTE.

Did Bonaparte desire to establish French colonial dominions in Australia? The case stated.

CHAPTER 7. GENESIS OF BAUDIN'S EXPEDITION.

Baudin's one of a series of French expeditions. The building up of the map of Australia. Early map-makers. Terra Australis. Dutch navigators. Emmerie Mollineux's map. Tasman and Dampier. The Petites Lettres of Maupertuis. De Brosses and his Histoire des Navigations aux Terres Australes. French voyages that originated from it. Bougainville; Marion-Dufresne; La Perouse; Bruni Dentrecasteaux. Voyages subsequent to Baudin's. The object of the voyages scientific and exploratory. The Institute of France and its proposition. Received by Bonaparte with interest. Bonaparte's interest in geography and travel. His authorisation of the expedition. The Committee of the Institute and their instructions. Fitting out of the expedition. Le Geographe and Le Naturaliste. The staff. Francois Peron. Captain Nicolas Baudin.

CHAPTER 8. EXODUS OF THE EXPEDITION.

The passports from the English Government. Sailing of the expedition. French interest in it. The case of Ah Sam. Baudin's obstinacy. Short supplies. The French ships on the Western Australian coast. The Ile Lucas and its name. Refreshment at Timor. The English frigate Virginia. Baudin sails south. Shortage of water. The French in Tasmania. Peron among the aboriginals. The savage and the boat. Among native women. A question of colour. Separation of the ships by storm. Baudin sails through Bass Strait, and meets Flinders. Scurvy. Great storms and intense suffering. Le Geographe at Port Jackson.

CHAPTER 9. PORT JACKSON AND KING ISLAND.

Le Naturaliste at Sydney. Boullanger's boat party. Curious conduct of Baudin. Le Naturaliste sails for Mauritius, but returns to Port Jackson. Re-union of Baudin's ships. Hospitality of Governor King. Peron's impressions of the British settlement. Morand, the banknote forger. Baudin shows his charts and instructions to King. Departure of the French ships. Rumours as to their objects. King's prompt action. The Cumberland sent after them. Acting Lieutenant Robbins at King Island. The flag incident. Baudin's letters to King. His protestations. Views on colonisation. Le Naturaliste sails for Europe.

CHAPTER 10. RETURN OF THE EXPEDITION.

Le Geographe sails for Kangaroo Island. Exploration of the two gulfs in the Casuarina by Freycinet. Baudin's erratic behaviour. Port Lincoln. Peron among the giants. A painful excursion. Second visit to Timor. Abandonment of north coast exploration. Baudin resolves to return home. Voyage to Mauritius. Death of Baudin. Treatment of him by Peron and Freycinet. Return of Le Geographe. Depression of the staff and crew.

Continue Reading →

Ernest Scott opens his study of French exploration in Australia with a frank admission: he once accepted the standard narrative of Napoleon's 1800–1804 expedition without question. Only after scrutinizing the primary sources did he find that 'opinions accepted with unquestioning faith began to crumble away for lack of evidence to support them.' This book is thus a revisionist history, one that carefully separates documented fact from what Scott calls a 'little sporadic Napoleonic legend.' The central figures are Captain Nicolas Baudin, commanding the French ships Le Géographe and Le Naturaliste, and Matthew Flinders, captain of the British Investigator, whose meeting in Encounter Bay becomes a pivotal scene.

A Meeting in Encounter Bay

Scott structures his narrative around the coincidental encounter of Flinders and Baudin in April 1802. The author uses this meeting as a fulcrum, contrasting the two captains' missions and characters. Flinders, already engaged in circumnavigating Australia, had charted the coast methodically. Baudin, by contrast, had made slow progress and lost men to illness. Scott notes that the French captain's own log reveals a man more interested in natural history than in territorial claims. The meeting itself is described with restraint: neither captain suspected the other of hostile intent. Scott's handling of this episode shows his method: he lets the documentary record—logbooks, letters, charts—speak, rather than imposing a dramatic narrative. The reader is left to weigh the evidence for themselves.

The Naming of Terre Napoleon

The book's title refers to the label applied to the southern Australian coastline on French maps published in 1807. Scott traces how this name originated not from Napoleon himself but from the expedition's cartographer, Louis de Freycinet. The author points out that Freycinet's atlas included the name despite Baudin's own charts showing no such designation. Scott's analysis of the mapmaking process reveals a key authorial choice: Freycinet, eager to please the imperial regime, inserted the name after the expedition's return. Scott supports this with evidence from the original manuscripts, showing that the name does not appear in Baudin's field notes. This observation underscores Scott's broader argument that the political interpretation of the voyage was constructed retrospectively.

Napoleon's Interest in Geography

Scott devotes considerable attention to Napoleon's personal engagement with the expedition, drawing on documents collected by Frédéric Masson. He notes that as a young officer, Napoleon had summarized a geography textbook in eight pages of notes, revealing a 'instinctive taste' for the subject. The First Consul's instruction that the French should appear among indigenous peoples 'comme des amis et des bienfaiteurs' is cited by Scott as evidence of a genuine, if paternalistic, interest. However, Scott also highlights a telling alteration: in 1824, Freycinet reissued the voyage narrative and replaced 'Napoleon personally expressed' with 'the government wished,' a change Scott calls 'a puerile piece of servility.' This detail exemplifies Scott's method of using textual variants to expose political pressures on historical records.

The Burden of Proof

Scott's preface lays out his historiographical approach with unusual candor. He acknowledges that historians must often rely on secondary authorities, but argues that when a specific claim—such as the assertion that Napoleon intended to invade Australia—lacks primary evidence, it must be discarded. The book's plan is to 'exhibit the facts' and then 'consider certain opinions' that have been current. Scott does not claim to have uncovered a conspiracy; rather, he shows how a legend grew from ambiguous sources. His tone is measured, even dry, but his argument is pointed: the burden of proof lies with those who assert a political motive. Readers should attend to Scott's footnotes, where he frequently cites archival materials and corrects errors in earlier historians' work.

Scott's book is best approached as a work of historical detection rather than a narrative of exploration. Readers will find the most value in the preface and the chapters that analyze the documentary record—logbooks, correspondence, and maps. The author's insistence on evidence over received opinion makes this a useful case study in how national myths are constructed and contested. Those seeking a straightforward account of Baudin's voyage should supplement this volume with primary sources, as Scott deliberately limits his scope to the question of political intent.

There’s something tender in how Scott untangles the quiet, misremembered work of the Baudin expedition—names half-erased by politics. It reminds me of another kind of patient perseverance, the sort Laura Haviland carried through her own labors. Reading her A Woman's Life-Work — Labors and Experiences of Laura S. Haviland — Story, Setting & Ideas feels like that same archaeology of the overlooked, and I’m grateful for both.